PRACTICE AREA

Surgery Negligence Claims

Surgical Negligence Claim2025-02-26T14:17:08+00:00

Surgical negligence claims fall under the umbrella of medical negligence claims, whereby a medical professional – in this instance a surgeon, has made a mistake during a surgical procedure. 

These mistakes can be serious, resulting in unnecessary pain to a patient, and in some cases, surgical negligence can even lead to loss of life.

If a personal injury is incurred as a result of surgical negligence – i.e. there was a mistake made during a surgery, and was not the result of a typical complication, then you may be within your right to make a surgical negligence claim. 

This money can help you recoup and cover any expenses lost due to your injury.

Read our case study on surgical negligence here.

Speak to us today

If you’ve suffered an injury or had an existing health condition made worse after clinical treatment, you may have suffered from medical negligence. That means you may be able to make a claim for compensation with the help of our expert solicitors.

What is Surgical Negligence?

Surgical negligence occurs when a surgeon, doctor or other healthcare assistant makes an error in a surgery, resulting in harm to a patient.

Claims for surgical negligence can be pursued when an individual believes that the hospital or medical practitioner fails to provide a reasonable standard of care. 

This is an important concept to understand when looking at making a surgical negligence claim. While surgical negligence is rare, unfortunately it does happen from time to time, and it is important to know your rights if you find yourself in this unpleasant situation.

Common Types of Surgical Errors

Thankfully, surgical errors are uncommon, however it is helpful to know the adverse incidents that can occur which lead to injury as a result of surgical errors by surgeons or other medical staff during a procedure. 

These range from minor errors made by a resulting in no harm, to grave mistakes which can result in a life-altering injury. Mistakes made in such treatment can even result in loss of life in some cases.

Claims for wrong-site operations refer to a situation whereby a surgeon operates on the incorrect part of the body — which, while a rare occurrence, does actually happen in some cases and can cause serious harm to a patient.

Retained surgical instruments is when a surgical team leaves any type of operating instrument within the body. 

If too much or too little anaesthesia is administered before a surgical procedure by a medical practitioner, this can lead to catastrophic pain, and in some cases brain damage or even loss of life.

Infections can occur as a result of medical negligence during a surgical procedure. Infections such as sepsis and bowel ischemia can be a result of internal bleeding, or other injuries incurred during a surgery, and can be fatal.

Nerve damage which results from a procedural mistake during a treatment causing a lot of unnecessary pain. Organs can also be damaged accidentally as a result of surgery negligence.

What should you do if you are a victim of surgical negligence?

There are a few steps you must undertake if you have been injured or harmed during a surgery, and wish to claim for medical negligence. The first thing to bear in mind is your time limit, or Statute of Limitations.

One of the main restrictions for filing a claim is the time limit, known as the Statute of Limitations. For medical negligence claims, the Statute of Limitations is 2 years less one day under Irish law. 

Awards for medical negligence can take some time to be finalised through the courts, however, the legal proceedings must begin within two years of the injury. 

There are some exceptions that you should be aware of, which prolong the time limit.

  • If you were under the age of 18 at the time of the injury, the 2 year limit starts on your 18th birthday
  • If you were unable to make a claim due to being in a coma
  • If any injury incurred did not present themselves immediately

Potential negligent surgery cases should be first raised with reliable medical negligence solicitors, giving you the best chance of a successful outcome. O’Reilly Doherty Solicitors are among the most respected medical negligence solicitors in Ireland.

Surgical Negligence Claims Compensation

There are two main types of personal injury damages that you can claim for depending on the type of harm that was done during a surgical procedure.

General damages are non-financial losses that are incurred as a result of a surgery – which are awarded after taking into account the effect a surgical procedure has had on the claimant’s personal life, excluding the monetary impact. Common general damages related to surgical claims include:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional distress
  • Disability 
  • Reputational damage

Each of these can have a major detrimental impact on someone’s life, and can sometimes be more difficult to quantify due to their subjectivity.

Special damages are easy to quantify as they can be proven by financial records, receipts and pay slips. Special damages refer to any monetary losses that a claimant has suffered as a result of a surgery, and can include:

  • Travel expenses
  • Lost earnings
  • Care and extra assistance costs
  • Other expenses related to care, such as wheelchairs

Special damages are generally not subjective, as there is a tangible and objective cost incurred by the claimant.

How much compensation you can receive as a result of surgical negligence in Ireland, in general or special damages, depends on the severity of the damages. 

Compensation varies from case to case, and contacting O’Reilly Doherty Solicitors, who have extensive expertise in medical negligence, is the best action to undertake if you think you have been a victim of negligence.

Proving Surgical Negligence

Negligent medical care can be proved by obtaining evidence to support the claim. The time it takes to prove negligence can vary, as cases can be extremely complex. 

For this reason, it is not uncommon for cases to last several years – and there is no set deadline for resolution of such cases. 

If the Defendant decides to defend the claim, two criteria must be met for a successful outcome for the injured party: negligence and causation.

Negligence refers to a failure to meet a reasonable standard of care, while causation refers to the harm caused to the patient. Both of these criteria must be met for the Judge to find in your favour.

Informed Consent in Irish Healthcare

Informed consent is a fundamental aspect of Irish healthcare, and essential for medical practitioners to ensure a duty of care. 

The HSE (Health Service Executive) states that each individual has the right to make decisions about their own treatment and care when spending time in a hospital or other healthcare facility.

Make a Surgical Negligence Claim Today

Get in touch with us at O’Reilly Doherty Solicitors today to discuss your options, and to get your surgical negligence claim process started.

FAQs

Medical negligence cases are handled by O’Reilly Doherty Solicitors’ experienced team of medical negligence solicitors.

Thankfully these days it is quite rare for surgical errors to occur, however mistakes can happen for a range of different reasons, so it is important to know what to do if you believe you are a victim of negligence.

The Statute of Limitations in Ireland for surgical negligence cases is two years, less one day from the time of the injury being incurred. There are some exceptions to this, in cases where the injured party is under 18 years, or in a coma.

You should seek a firm with a dedicated medical negligence team with expertise and a track record in such cases. O’Reilly Doherty Solicitors has a successful track record in claims for medical negligence.

For negligence within the public healthcare system, the HSE pays compensation through the State Claims Agency, which is designated by the government to resolve claims. This is funded by public money.

Client Testimonials

Very professional service from start to finish, the communication was great and the whole process was made as stress free as possible. I would highly recommend Ronan and the team.

Paul Spillane, ★★★★★

I have used Ronan and O’Reilly Doherty both professionally and personally, I couldn’t recommend them anymore just brilliant to deal with from start to finish. Thanks Guys.

Gareth Logan, ★★★★★

Fantastic to deal with would highly recommend.

Niall Conway, ★★★★★

Very friendly and extremely helpful. Thank you.

Noleen Burke, ★★★★★

Superb service, cannot recommend them highly enough.

Ian Grimson, ★★★★★

More Medical Negligence Resources

Go to Top